Who Gets to Draw the Line?

IV. The Photographer’s Own Gaze – Nude Photography, Consent and the Sacred

After films, images and novels, the question has to turn back to me. I photograph the nude. That makes me more than an observer of transgressions: I am also someone whose images can touch people’s boundaries.

The image that runs through this series makes that clear. A naked woman at the cross: for many, this will be a religious provocation, perhaps an offence against the sacred. The image is not a neutral illustration. I know the cross carries powerful meaning. My intention alone does not determine how the image will be read.

But the audience’s reaction does not answer every other question either. What appears to be a transgression in an image is not automatically the same as a boundary violation during its making. To consider that, I also have to look at how the image came about: Who had a say? What had been agreed? Could the model say no?

A particular experience from a photography week in Italy has stayed with me. We found an old, abandoned, dilapidated, secularized church—a wonderful location for a shoot. One of the two models had no problem with posing nude there. The other declined, referring to her faith. Her decision was respected.

The church had been secularized. For this model, it was still not simply an empty room with beautiful light. Personal faith does not automatically disappear when a building’s official religious status changes. And the other model’s consent did not make the first model’s refusal excessive. Two people, two boundaries.

To me, that points to an important distinction: a personal boundary calls for a personal response. A model’s no is not an invitation to argue it away. But it also does not automatically mean everyone must draw the same line. In this case, the decision was clear: we respected the refusal and photographed there with the other model.

That still does not answer how I should deal with the finished image and its effect. A model can agree to a photograph while viewers find the result offensive, blasphemous or beautiful. The consent of the people involved addresses one layer. The image’s cultural and religious meaning is another.

For me, nudity alone is not intimacy, and a nude image is not automatically erotic. That is my approach to the work. Others may read the image differently. I cannot decide their response for them. But I have to ask myself whether my own gaze sees the model as a person—or merely shapes her into my own idea.

Where, then, does artistic freedom end? I do not think there is a line that can be drawn once and applied to everyone. Laws change. Societies change. Religious and personal meanings differ. But that does not mean every boundary is arbitrary. In the work itself, there are responsibilities: listen, take agreements seriously and respect a no. The finished work carries another responsibility: do not confuse your own intention with the only possible interpretation.

Perhaps art may approach a boundary, make it visible and even cross it. But the words “This is art” cannot spare me the work of examining myself. Whose boundary does my image touch? Who had a say in making it? And what am I willing to learn about its effect instead of dismissing that effect too quickly as a misunderstanding?

This series does not end with a final answer. The four contributions have looked at different boundaries: between artist and model, in the depiction of naked bodies, in the telling of violence, and finally in my own photographic work. The questions can be asked. We have not found an answer that applies to everyone. Perhaps the value of the series lies in keeping those questions open—and looking more closely the next time someone draws a line.

Scroll to Top