I. A sculptor, a girl—and the word art
My Cogitationes rarely begin with a finished thesis. Usually, all it takes is something that unsettles me. Something doesn’t quite fit. I get stuck on it, start picking it apart—and suddenly questions open up that seem only loosely connected to the original prompt.
This time, it was a synopsis of Laura, les ombres de l’été, a 1979 film by David Hamilton. I saw Bilitis at some point as a teenager. It didn’t leave me with any urgent desire to catch up on Hamilton’s filmography now. His soft focus: It can work. It doesn’t have to.
But I couldn’t let the synopsis go.
It tells the story of Paul, a sculptor in the midst of a creative crisis. He meets Sarah again, a former lover, and her daughter Laura. Laura is fifteen and reminds him of Sarah when she was young. Paul wants her to model for him. At first, Sarah allows him to work only from photographs; Laura herself is not to come to his studio. The retelling also describes Laura as fascinated by Paul and willing to pose for him in person.
This is not a film review. I haven’t seen the film. The transcript I found is a retelling, not a record of the film’s dialogue. And that retelling is not neutral either: first it presents the film as a gentle coming-of-age story, then as a story of obsessive boundary-crossing, and finally as the sculptor’s redemption. The way the film is presented is already putting interpretations into circulation.
My unease is not that an artist is dealing with a difficult subject. It lies in the question of what the word art is meant to do in this story. Does it describe Paul’s activity? Or does it become an explanation for why his fascination may be made to seem like something higher?
A sculptor turns a person into an image. That is part of the nature of artistic work: to observe, select, shape, discard. But Laura is not just any model in this story. She is fifteen. Paul is an adult man and an artist she admires. Even if she is attracted to him and wants to pose for him, the imbalance between them does not disappear. Her desire is part of her story. But it does not, by itself, determine the responsibility Paul bears.
Sarah draws a boundary too—at least at first. Laura is not to come to Paul’s studio; the sculpture is to be made from photographs. But Sarah is not only a mother. She was involved with Paul herself and seems emotionally entangled in the situation. Her permission and her prohibition cannot simply be read as pure concern for Laura.
And what does working from photographs actually mean? It creates distance between artist and model. But does that distance protect Laura? Or does it give Paul the chance to be alone with her image and shape it according to his own ideas? A photograph is not a neutral substitute for a person. It shows a body from a particular point of view—and can turn a person into an idea.
This is where the questions begin to branch out. A boundary can lie within the work: in what is shown. It can lie in the process of making it: in the relationship between artist and model. It may become visible only in the audience’s response or through the intervention of an institution.
These things should not be collapsed into a single moral line. A work can disturb people without anyone having been exploited in its making. Conversely, an aesthetically restrained image does not prove that the process behind it was unproblematic. Saying “It’s art” does not resolve the question of responsibility. But a viewer’s outrage, by itself, does not prove that a boundary has been crossed either.
The film was released theatrically in France in 1979 and was also issued on commercial VHS. A contemporary review in Le Monde criticised the plot as almost nonexistent and found the film’s strongest moments in Hamilton’s unmistakable visual style. So it would be wrong to call it a film that was banned at the time. What is more interesting is that even the contemporary review considered the visual impact and the narrative separately.
Perhaps that is where this series really begins. Not with the claim that every crossing of a boundary is courageous. Nor with the demand that art accommodate every sensitivity. But with the more precise question: Who is drawing whose boundary here—and who bears the consequences?
In Laura, that question leads to the relationship between artist, model and image. In other works, it will be about naked bodies being covered; texts being altered after the fact; violence remaining in a story; and, eventually, my own work with the nude.
The chain of thoughts begins with a film I’m not particularly eager to see. For now, it ends with a question that is not so easily softened out of focus: When is “art” a description—and when is the word meant to excuse something?
