Why the most unremarkable photographs in the modelling world are genuinely useful – and why they have never interested me when choosing my own models.
A Small Thank You
Occasionally, a model asks me whether I could take a few Polas for them. I am happy to do so, even if I have hired and paid the model for my own artistic work. I do not charge anything extra. For me, it is a small gesture of appreciation and a way of saying thank you for our collaboration. For the model, these pictures can be genuinely useful for applications, castings or their own model profile.
These photographs are fundamentally different from my usual work. No dramatic lighting, no unusual poses, no elaborate compositions and, above all, no beauty retouching. The model stands against a neutral background, looks into the camera, turns to the side and is photographed from several angles. The artistic demands are roughly comparable to those of a passport photograph. That is not meant to be dismissive. After all, nobody expects a passport photo to answer the great questions of human existence.
But what exactly are these photographs used for?
From Polaroid to Pola
The term Polas comes from Polaroids. Originally, these photographs were taken with instant cameras. This was practical: a model arrived at an agency or casting, was photographed, and shortly afterwards there were up-to-date pictures available. There was no need to have a roll of film developed before anyone could assess what the person actually looked like.
The commercial history of Polaroid instant photography began in 1948 with Edwin H. Land’s camera. It is difficult to establish precisely when modelling agencies first began using such photographs systematically. Today, Polas are generally taken digitally and are often called digitals internationally. The original name has survived nevertheless. One of those little linguistic achievements in which the technology has long since changed while the terminology cheerfully carries on.
The requirements are straightforward. The model is photographed as naturally as possible, usually without makeup or with very little, with natural hair and simple, close-fitting clothing. The background should be neutral and the lighting as even as possible. Typical photographs include front-facing and profile headshots as well as full-length images from different angles. Retouching, elaborate styling and deliberately flattering staging are avoided. Exact requirements vary between agencies.
Polas therefore serve a different purpose from the photographs in a model’s portfolio. While a portfolio is intended to demonstrate the different looks, moods and expressive possibilities that can be achieved with a model, Polas primarily document their current physical appearance. A model card, often called a comp card, combines selected photographs with essential information about the model and may include these neutral images.
Polas are certainly not relics of a bygone era. The German-language platform model-kartei.de, for example, has a dedicated “Polaroids” section on model profiles. Its search function even allows users to filter for models who have uploaded Polas. Their usefulness is therefore by no means restricted to major international modelling agencies. They also have a practical role in the independent photography and modelling community.
Practical Photography Rather Than Art
Polas are purely functional photographs. Their purpose is to document a person as faithfully as possible so that photographers, agencies and clients can assess whether their appearance is suitable for a particular assignment.
Photographically, this is not especially challenging. A sensible perspective, even lighting, correct exposure and sharp focus are generally all that is required. A smartphone can be perfectly adequate. Anyone wishing to turn this into an independent form of photographic high art has probably also discovered previously unsuspected creative possibilities in taking passport photographs.
Of course, even such an image is never completely objective. Camera height affects perceived proportions, an unfortunate perspective can exaggerate parts of the body, and strongly directional lighting makes facial features appear different from how they look under even illumination. A Pola is therefore also the result of photographic decisions. The aim, however, is precisely to minimise their influence rather than deliberately stage the photograph.
A good Pola does not have to be particularly beautiful. Above all, it has to fulfil its purpose: to give the viewer a reasonably reliable idea of who will actually turn up in front of the camera.
The Canvas and Its Possibilities
One might say that, in Polas, a model presents themselves as a kind of canvas on which a picture will later be created. The styling, lighting, staging and expression have not yet been determined. A client first wants to know what physical characteristics the person brings to the assignment.
For some photographic tasks, this is extremely important. In fashion photography, proportions and clothing sizes must match the garments. In a beauty campaign, facial features, hair or skin may play a decisive role. Other productions may be looking specifically for an unusual appearance that differs from conventional beauty ideals. There is, after all, no single perfect body for every photographic assignment.
The canvas metaphor does have its limits, however. A model is not an inanimate material that can be shaped at will. They bring personality, experience, abilities and their own means of expression. And this is precisely where the aspects that interest me as an artistic photographer begin – aspects that matter far more to me than appearance alone.
Why Polas Do Not Interest Me When Choosing Models
I must admit that Polas have never interested me when selecting my own models. Not because I consider them pointless, but because they fail to provide precisely the information I am looking for.
For my artistic work under the name Artis Umbrae, I need people who can express something through their bodies. People who communicate emotions not merely with their faces but through their entire posture. Who can develop unusual poses, create tension, shape movement and immerse themselves in an artistic concept. What interests me is whether a model can convincingly embody a role and whether we can develop a shared visual language that corresponds to my idea.
Hardly any of this can be recognised in a Pola. Someone may look completely unremarkable in a neutral full-length photograph and develop extraordinary expressive power in front of my camera. Conversely, a model with an impressive appearance may struggle to convey a particular emotion or posture convincingly.
A beautiful face, after all, does not automatically make a good actor. And a well-proportioned body does not tell a story by itself.
This is also why personal attraction is not a decisive factor when I choose models. Some of my favourite models are not at all the kind of people I find physically attractive as a man. Nevertheless, they are among my preferred artistic collaborators because they possess something that cannot be expressed in body measurements or judged from neutral full-length photographs: expressive ability.
None of this is intended to diminish the importance of Polas for other photographic purposes. When an agency is looking for a model for a particular fashion production, physical characteristics are important selection criteria. When I want to portray a character embodying despair, inner tension or strength, however, I need to know whether someone can communicate those emotions convincingly. For that, I need different information from a front-facing and a profile photograph.
Polas show what a person looks like. Their artistic potential is quite another matter.
The Same Camera, Two Different Tasks
Perhaps this contrast is the most interesting thing about Polas. With the same camera, I can produce a relatively factual record of someone’s appearance or attempt to realise a complex artistic vision. The medium is the same, yet the tasks could hardly be more different.
With Polas, the photographer and their visual style should remain as unobtrusive as possible. In my artistic work, by contrast, light, composition, posture and expression are deliberately employed to create a particular statement. One documents physical characteristics. The other attempts to create something from those characteristics that goes beyond mere appearance.
And that is precisely why, when choosing models, I am not primarily interested in people who look especially attractive in a neutral photograph. I am interested in those who can make something visible in front of my camera that previously existed only as an idea.
Polas show me a person’s body. What they can tell with it is another story.
Sources and Further Reading
- Paragon Models: What are Polas / Polaroids? – requirements for natural model photographs.
- SHOWCAST: Polaroids / Digitals – their use by agencies and at castings.
- Model-Kartei: model-kartei.de – model profiles with a dedicated Polaroids section.
- WIMA Models: Create Digitals – practical requirements from a modelling agency.
- Digital Public Library of America: The Polaroid Era – the development of instant photography.
