I’m Not Photogenic! – Why We Often Don’t Like Ourselves in Photographs

There are activities people genuinely look forward to: dinner with friends, a concert, a lovely holiday, or an afternoon with no obligations at all. And then there is a visit to the photographer.

For some people, it probably ranks on their personal popularity scale somewhere just behind a visit to the proctologist. The two experiences have at least one thing in common: you feel observed, may have to reveal things you would rather keep to yourself, and hope the whole affair will be over quickly.

Of course, that comparison is a little unfair. To proctologists, that is.

But seriously: why do so many people dislike being photographed? Why do women I find genuinely interesting assure me, before I have even taken the first picture, that they are not photogenic at all? And why does a lively, expressive person sometimes turn into a stiff figure within seconds of a camera being pointed at them?

The answer has surprisingly little to do with photographic technique. More often, it has to do with self-image, fear of being judged, and the slightly unpleasant experience of looking different in photographs than we do in our own minds.

Let us start with the mirror. Most people look at their face in one almost every day, often enough to know exactly which side they prefer and from which angle their nose appears, in their opinion, slightly less nose-like. The problem is that mirrors reverse us.

In photographs, by contrast, we usually see the version other people know. That is why a picture can seem strange to us even though everyone else sees nothing unusual in it. Psychological research has long suggested that people tend to prefer their mirror image, while friends and acquaintances often prefer the familiar, unreversed view. This is not a dramatic discovery, but it is a comforting one: when we think we look odd in a photograph, it may simply be because we are seeing ourselves in an unfamiliar way.

Our brains like what is familiar. They do not necessarily find it more beautiful because it is objectively better, but because it is the version they know. The camera does not have to reveal anything unkind about us. It may simply show us a version of ourselves we have not yet learned to recognize.

There is another complication: we usually inspect ourselves with a level of scrutiny we would never apply to anyone else. No one looks at a friend and thinks, “Her left eyelid is two millimetres lower today.” Yet we can perform that particular analysis on ourselves with remarkable dedication.

Psychology calls this, among other things, the spotlight effect. We regularly overestimate how closely other people observe our appearance and behaviour. What feels like a glaring flaw to us is often a detail that others have not even noticed. Or, more likely, they are busy worrying about their own supposed flaws.

That also explains why people suddenly mention things in front of a camera that may not usually occupy their minds all day. “Please do not photograph my upper arms,” “My stomach must not be visible,” or “I do not have a good side.” Sometimes this is followed by a surprisingly detailed guided tour of all the body parts that must under no circumstances appear in a photograph. Meanwhile, the photographer is standing there, thinking about light, composition and posture, and wondering whether to start by the window or the wall.

These concerns should not be dismissed. If someone says they do not want to show a certain part of their body, they mean it, and that must be respected. But it can help to remember that our own critical gaze is not automatically everyone else’s gaze. What a person has disliked about themselves for years may be insignificant to others – or even an interesting and distinctive feature.

Another finding from research fits this rather well: we are often not especially good at choosing the photograph that represents us best. In studies, profile pictures selected by other people frequently created a more favourable impression than those selected by the people in the photographs themselves.

That does not mean photographers always know which image a client must like. The point is not to explain to someone which picture they ought to find beautiful. But it does remind us that self-perception and outside perception are two different things. While I may see an interesting line, an open expression or beautiful light, a client may first notice the small detail she dislikes about herself. Neither of us has to be wrong. We are simply looking at the same picture with different expectations.

I saw how strong this uncertainty can be during a social project. I photographed the staff of a charitable organisation whose work I deeply admire, free of charge. The organisation supports people who urgently need psychotherapy but cannot afford it.

About two-thirds of the people greeted me with some version of: “I hate having my picture taken.”

My immediate – and, of course, entirely unspoken – response was something like: “I am looking forward to working with you too. This is really making my day.”

Naturally, that would not have been a particularly helpful answer. A sentence like that is rarely a rejection of photography or of the photographer. More often, it means: “Please do not judge me by my appearance.” Or: “I have no idea what I am supposed to do in front of a camera.” Perhaps it means: “I am afraid that the final photograph will confirm every insecurity I have about myself.”

That is why a photographer’s work begins long before the first click of the shutter. Nobody has to be photogenic. Nobody has to know how to stand, where to put their hands, or which side is their better side. That is, after all, the photographer’s responsibility. The person in front of the camera should not feel as if they are sitting an exam for which they have unfortunately not studied.

It is especially helpful not to begin shooting immediately. A conversation, a coffee, a short walk around the space, or simply a few minutes without any photographic expectation can do more than the most sophisticated pose. The camera can be present without immediately taking centre stage.

Language matters as well. “Just relax” is about as useful as telling someone not to think of a pink elephant. Small, concrete instructions work much better: “Turn your shoulder slightly towards me,” “Put your weight on your back leg,” or “Look briefly past the window.” The person being photographed should not have to guess what “natural” is supposed to mean.

Because nothing feels natural in front of a camera at first. Naturalness arrives only when people stop constantly watching themselves. That takes time, calm, and the sense that they are not at someone else’s mercy.

Control matters too. Some people want to see the pictures as they are being taken. Others become more nervous when they do, because they begin checking every detail. Both reactions are perfectly valid. A photographer can ask how much insight feels comfortable during the session, and those wishes can change at any time. Anyone who dislikes a pose, an outfit or a particular crop should be able to say so without having to justify it.

The same applies after the shoot. An enormous, unfiltered collection of images helps very few people. It is more likely to result in someone putting twenty almost identical photographs next to one another and, after fifteen minutes, becoming convinced that they do not look human in any of them. A careful preselection is therefore not patronising; it is often a relief. It does not show every awkward moment between poses, but the images in which expression, posture and light come together.

One might think our time should have made all of this easier. Never before have so many people been photographed. We carry cameras in our pockets, take endless selfies, delete unsuccessful images immediately, and can rely on filters, retouching and artificial light when necessary. Surely we should all be perfectly relaxed in front of a camera by now.

Not necessarily.

Research suggests that constant attention to our own image does not automatically make us more satisfied with it. When we repeatedly photograph, inspect, select and optimise ourselves, we may simply discover new details that supposedly need improving: smoother skin, a narrower waist, a more flattering angle. Technology offers almost limitless possibilities. Unfortunately, it also offers almost limitless reasons to become dissatisfied.

Perhaps that is one of the differences between a selfie and a good portrait. In a selfie, you are simultaneously the subject, photographer, director, editor and particularly strict critic. You have complete control – and therefore bear complete responsibility for making the result live up to your expectations. That is surprisingly exhausting.

In a good photographic session, by contrast, you can hand over part of that responsibility. Not control over your limits, wishes or images. But the pressure to do everything perfectly on your own. You do not need to know what you look like when you laugh. You do not have to keep wondering whether your chin is at an unfortunate angle. You can rely on someone whose job it is to look carefully.

When a woman contacts me about a session, I often say that I do not really do photo shoots. We celebrate her beauty. That may sound slightly theatrical, but it describes rather precisely the atmosphere I want to create.

I have described this philosophy before in my article “Sensuality Is Not a Question of How Many Buttons Are Undone”. The point is that a woman should not experience her time in the studio as a photographic examination in which she has to meet as many expectations as possible. She should have time to arrive, become familiar with the situation and express her wishes. My job is to create the photographic conditions, not to press her into a particular ideal of beauty.

Before the appointment, every client receives a questionnaire. I ask about her ideas, the images she would like and her personal boundaries. Supposed problem areas can be discussed as well. It may happen that I find a part of her body photographically interesting that she dislikes completely. Conversely, she may especially want to show something that is less suitable for a particular composition.

I look at these things from the perspective of a photographer working with form, proportion and light, not from that of a man judging personal attractiveness. Of course, I can make suggestions. But whatever a woman does not want to show stays outside the picture. She does not need to be persuaded by my aesthetic opinion. It is not the case that only I should be satisfied with the result.

Hospitality is part of the celebration as well. In the questionnaire, I ask what my client likes to eat and drink. When she arrives, I have something small prepared. We start with a conversation, take our time, and take breaks during the session too. Wine or prosecco are available on request, as are non-alcoholic drinks, naturally. A glass of prosecco may be a pleasant companion for an afternoon, but it is neither a requirement for relaxation nor an especially effective photographic tool.

What does all this have to do with photography? Quite a lot. A person who feels uncomfortable moves more cautiously, tenses their shoulders and tries to maintain a highly controlled posture. This affects more than facial expression. The back, arms, stomach and hips change shape when the body is tense.

The more comfortable a woman feels, the easier it becomes for her to try unfamiliar movements and suggestions. She no longer has to wonder constantly whether she is doing everything correctly, and can focus increasingly on what we are creating together. A monitor on which she can view the developing images can be especially useful. Sometimes it is only then that she understands why a particular posture works, or why I asked her to turn her shoulder slightly. Other clients prefer to see the results only at the end. That is equally worthy of respect.

Trust does not come from constant compliments. I am not particularly fond of telling a woman repeatedly during a session how beautiful she is. At some point, it begins to sound like a poorly programmed voice assistant. It is far more helpful to work attentively, explain my decisions clearly and honestly show the photographic possibilities I see.

A photograph is not objective proof of what a person looks like. Perspective, distance and light all change appearance considerably. A face can look very different depending on camera position, and the same posture can be transformed entirely by different lighting.

A photograph is always an interpretation. The photographer decides what is visible, how it is shown and what importance light and framing are given. This is true even when no digital editing has taken place. Reality is not stored neutrally; it is translated into a two-dimensional image through many decisions.

That carries responsibility. When a woman sees a photograph of herself, she may see more than an image. She may see what she believes to be a statement about her appearance. An unfortunate lighting angle can quickly be interpreted as a personal flaw, even though it was first and foremost a photographic decision.

Conversely, a successful image can reveal something that is barely noticed in everyday life: an unusual posture, a particular expression, a beautiful line, or simply a natural ease that disappears as soon as someone begins looking at themselves too critically. Not because photography invents a prettier truth, but because it makes one of many possible truths visible.

That does not mean everyone will suddenly be at peace with themselves after a successful portrait. Photography is not psychotherapy, and an afternoon in a studio cannot remove every insecurity. That would be a rather presumptuous claim.

But photography can create a space in which someone is not judged, pressured or corrected. It can offer time and attention. It can show that one’s own critical gaze is not the only possible gaze. And perhaps it can make someone curious to step in front of the camera – not because they must finally look perfect, but because it can be interesting to see themselves differently.

If, afterwards, a woman not only likes her photographs but also remembers the afternoon fondly, then more has been achieved than a technically good image.

And perhaps the photographer has even moved ahead of the proctologist on her personal popularity scale. Which would be a start.

Sources

Mita, T. H., Dermer, M. & Knight, J. (1977): Reversed Facial Images and the Mere-Exposure Hypothesis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 35(8), 597–601. DOI: 10.1037/0022-3514.35.8.597

White, D., Sutherland, C. A. M. & Burton, A. L. (2017): Choosing Face: The Curse of Self in Profile Image Selection. Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications, 2, Article 23. DOI: 10.1186/s41235-017-0058-3

Gilovich, T., Medvec, V. H. & Savitsky, K. (2000): The Spotlight Effect in Social Judgment: An Egocentric Bias in Estimates of the Salience of One’s Own Actions and Appearance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78(2), 211–222. DOI: 10.1037/0022-3514.78.2.211

Mills, J. S., Musto, S., Williams, L. & Tiggemann, M. (2018): “Selfie” Harm: Effects on Mood and Body Image in Young Women. Body Image, 27, 86–92. DOI: 10.1016/j.bodyim.2018.08.007

Scroll to Top