The Devil, the Onion, and the Forgotten Heroine

On shifting perspectives in art, religious outrage, and the question of who actually deserves a monument.

Today, I stumbled across a devil on YouTube. Not in person, of course, but a bronze statue in the historic centre of Esslingen am Neckar, Germany. A rather indignant gentleman was explaining why erecting a monument to the Devil was deeply troubling. After all, salvation comes from Jesus Christ, not from the Prince of Darkness. Or something along those lines. I must confess that I did not quite catch the finer points of his theological argument. I thought it wiser to keep scrolling before he invited me to join him in evening prayers.

Nevertheless, the man had, presumably unintentionally, aroused my curiosity.

So I took a closer look at the statue. An oversized devil, complete with horns, protruding tongue, grotesque expression, and an onion in his hand. Created by artist Tim Bengel, the sculpture was installed in October 2026 and presented to the city by the Kessler sparkling wine company to mark its 200th anniversary.

The sculpture is called Zwieblinger Teufel — the Onion Devil — and refers to a local legend explaining why the inhabitants of Esslingen are still nicknamed Zwieblinger, or “onion people”.

The story is quickly told. The Devil appears at the Esslingen market disguised as a man and asks for a red apple. A clever market woman recognises him by his cloven hoof and the smell of sulphur. Instead of the apple, she hands him an onion. The Devil bites into it greedily, realises he has been tricked, and flies into a rage. He insults the people of Esslingen, calls them onions, and storms out of town. Supposedly, he was never seen there again.

A remarkably modest effort to rid oneself of the Prince of Darkness. No exorcisms, no elaborate rituals involving holy water, no lengthy theological reports. One onion was enough.

One might think this settles the question of who deserves a monument in this story.

But it is not quite that simple.

Who Gets the Bronze?

Tim Bengel chose not to depict the victorious market woman, but the Devil at the moment of his defeat. And I can certainly understand that decision.

A devil with horns, a contorted face, and an onion in his hand offers considerable visual possibilities. A medieval market woman holding a vegetable, perhaps somewhat fewer. Although I would hesitate to regard that as an immutable law of art. An elderly woman standing before an overwhelmingly powerful opponent with a mischievous smile could make a remarkable sculpture. As so often, it depends on what the artist makes of it.

Bengel’s decision is, in any case, a shift in perspective. We do not see the story from the viewpoint of the victor, but through the reaction of the defeated. The mighty Devil, supposedly a master of temptation and deception, has fallen for an absurdly simple trick.

There is a delightful irony in that. Centuries of theological warnings about the Devil’s cunning, and in the end, an onion does the job.

Bengel himself explains that he deliberately wanted to portray the Devil as the defeated party, certainly not as a hero. He also consciously omitted the market woman, leaving viewers free to imagine her for themselves.

That is a perfectly understandable artistic approach. Art does not have to depict every character in a story, and omission can sometimes communicate more than a complete illustration.

But it raises another question for me: What happens to a story when we shift its centre of attention?

A Wolf, a Saint, and the Question of Freedom

Such shifts in perspective are familiar territory in my own work. In my photography, I repeatedly draw upon historical, mythological, and religious narratives. What interests me is less their faithful illustration than what happens when we examine them from a different angle.

One example is my series DE LUPO DOMITO, which explores the legend of the Wolf of Gubbio.

According to tradition, a wolf terrorised the inhabitants of the Umbrian town of Gubbio. Francis of Assisi approached the animal, spoke to it, and negotiated a peace agreement. The townspeople promised to feed the wolf, while the animal pledged never to harm anyone again.

A beautiful story about peace, understanding, and the power of a saint.

But is it also a beautiful story from the wolf’s perspective?

What does it mean for a wild animal to be tamed? Is it salvation when it no longer has to go hungry? Or does it lose part of its essential nature? Is adapting to a community a gain in security, or a loss of freedom?

In my photographic interpretation, I was therefore less interested in the saint’s triumph than in the possible tragedy of the wolf. Rather than simply accepting the traditional moral framework, I wanted to examine it from another perspective.

A shift in perspective can change the meaning of a story. Not by rewriting its events, but by asking different questions of them.

And that is precisely why Bengel’s decision interests me.

What Does the Devil Tell Us?

Bengel shows the Devil at the moment he has lost his superiority. It is visually appealing, but does it also change our understanding of the legend?

I am not entirely convinced.

The Devil remains the villain. The market woman remains the clever victor. The moral structure of the story is not challenged. We merely experience the decisive moment from another viewpoint.

That is not necessarily a shortcoming. Not every work of art needs to offer a philosophical reassessment of its source material. Condensing a narrative into a single expressive moment can itself be a considerable artistic achievement.

But there is another factor here: public space.

A monumental bronze statue in a historic square is more than just a representation. It claims attention, permanence, and significance. For centuries, we have erected monuments to rulers, generals, saints, and other figures whose memory we wish to preserve.

Of course, a monument can also be ironic. There is a certain wit in depicting a defeated Devil on a monumental scale. The more powerful he appears, the more ridiculous his defeat by an ordinary onion becomes.

But does that irony work without knowing the legend?

Anyone unfamiliar with the Esslingen market woman initially sees an imposing devil. The onion in his hand may arouse curiosity, but the actual heroine remains invisible.

The woman acts. The Devil reacts. Yet he is the one given monumental form.

Bengel wants us to imagine the woman ourselves. That is legitimate. In my own work with shadows, reduction, and omission, I know how powerful the unseen can be.

But an omission is not automatically an artistic statement. For the invisible to become effective, its absence must somehow be felt. Otherwise, it simply remains invisible.

Perhaps that is precisely where I question Bengel’s decision. Not because he depicts the Devil, but because I wonder whether the woman has been pushed too far into the background.

At least she receives a mention on the pedestal. The sculpture is dedicated to the women of Esslingen who once drove the Devil from the city through courage and cunning.

So the women get the dedication. The Devil gets the bronze.

When the Devil Frightens the Faithful

That a depiction of the Devil in a public square should provoke religious outrage surprises me less than the intensity of the reactions.

There is a petition against the statue, the sculpture has been vandalised with paint, and even calls for murder have appeared online. The city of Esslingen has announced that it will take action against criminal statements.

Consider that for a moment.

For centuries, Christian artists have depicted the Devil in churches, frescoes, portals, and scenes of the Last Judgement. Think of the demons of medieval art or the visions of hell painted by Hieronymus Bosch. Apparently, depicting evil was perfectly compatible with Christianity for many centuries.

Now a devil holding an onion is enough to plunge some contemporaries into a crisis of faith.

What I find remarkable is the considerably more relaxed response of the Protestant Church. Klaus-Peter Lüdke, the Protestant dean of Esslingen, pointed out that a depiction of the Devil has existed on the city’s Frauenkirche for centuries. Nor does he regard the new sculpture as a religious threat.

Perhaps it would help to distinguish between depicting a figure and worshipping it. European art history would certainly appreciate the effort.

The controversy has also acquired a political dimension. According to Esslingen’s mayor, some of the fiercest criticism comes from strongly religious and right-wing populist circles. The local AfD had already voted against accepting the sculpture. Initially, its official objections concerned the lack of public participation and the selection process. In a later statement, however, AfD councillor Stephan Köthe also argued explicitly on religious grounds and called for the statue to be replaced with a depiction of the women of Esslingen.

What is interesting here is how differently religious attempts to influence public space are perceived. While certain political groups passionately warn against political Islam and its ambitions to shape society, this controversy demonstrates that demands to restrict public art on religious grounds are by no means confined to one faith.

This does not mean that a petition against a statue should be equated with Islamist extremism. Such a comparison would be absurd. But the underlying question remains: To what extent should religious beliefs determine what art a secular society may display?

Ironically, representatives of the Protestant Church are defending artistic freedom.

Perhaps there is another irony here: theologians find themselves having to explain to certain defenders of Christian civilisation that a bronze statue is neither a profession of faith nor an invitation to worship the Devil.

Taste and artistic quality are legitimate subjects of debate. So is the question of whether the Devil or the market woman would have been the more suitable subject. Vandalism and death threats, however, are not art criticism. They demonstrate a remarkable inability to tolerate differing perspectives.

Snow White Sends Her Regards

The affair reminds me somewhat of the Snow White monument in Lohr am Main, a town in Franconia.

There, sculptor Peter Wittstadt created an unusual, highly abstract interpretation of the fairy-tale character. The local population apparently had a rather more charming princess in mind. The result promptly acquired the less-than-flattering nickname Horrorwittchen — roughly, “Horror White”.

Here, too, art became a public irritation when it failed to meet expectations. In Lohr, the debate centred primarily on aesthetics. In Esslingen, religious convictions and the question of who deserves recognition within a traditional narrative have entered the discussion.

What both works have in common is that their creators did not choose the most agreeable representation. And both achieved something that is far from automatic: their works are noticed. They engage people, provoke approval and opposition.

Of course, provocation alone does not make good art. Otherwise, we would have to declare social media comment sections part of humanity’s intangible cultural heritage.

But art that unsettles our assumptions and prompts us to question what we take for granted has at least fulfilled one of its possibilities.

Whatever objections one may have to Bengel’s Devil, one thing is difficult to deny: his work has moved people.

Whether the sculpture will still be artistically compelling in twenty years or eventually become merely a curious tourist attraction, nobody can know. But it has already encouraged people to engage with a regional legend, religious ideas, and the meaning of public monuments.

Including me.

Until today, I knew nothing about Esslingen’s onion legend. Now I find myself thinking at length about a medieval market woman, her unusual method of dealing with the Devil, and why her opponent, of all people, has been given a monumental bronze statue.

The Woman Nobody Sees

We know countless depictions of powerful men, their opponents, their victories, and their defeats. Yet those whose actions made these stories possible often remain nameless. Women, in particular, have frequently been less visible in traditional historical representations than their actual significance would suggest.

I do not wish to suggest that Bengel consciously perpetuates this tradition. There is no reason to assume that. His decision has an artistic justification, and a statue is hardly an illustrated encyclopaedia obliged to depict every participant.

Nevertheless, a curious imbalance remains.

The Devil receives a monumental bronze statue. The woman who defeated him exists only in the story and in our imagination.

One could regard that as a mistake. But perhaps it is precisely the work’s unintended strength.

For Bengel’s Devil has made me think about a woman whose name nobody knows. About her intelligence, her courage, and why we so often depict the spectacular figures of a story while those who actually make things happen disappear into the background.

Whether the artist intended precisely that, I cannot say. Perhaps he would agree with my interpretation; perhaps he would disagree.

Art, after all, is not a contract in which the artist determines the only permissible meaning. A work begins a life of its own the moment it is viewed. And the viewer’s thoughts need not coincide with those of its creator.

In the end, we are left with a Devil defeated by an onion, an invisible heroine, and a city arguing over a bronze statue.

Perhaps the market woman has won after all. We are talking about her again, even though she lived centuries ago and did not even leave us her name.

The Devil stands in the town square.

But the story belongs to her.


Sources and Further Reading

  • City of Esslingen am Neckar: Official information on the Zwieblinger Teufel sculpture, October 2026, and statement on the vandalism of 12 October 2026.
  • City of Esslingen: The onion legend as recorded by Dorothee Bayer in Esslinger Heimatbuch (1982).
  • SWR Aktuell: Reports on the controversy, death threats, and statements by the artist, city administration, and Church, October 2026.
  • Evangelical Lutheran Church in Württemberg: Warum eine Teufelsfigur Empörung und Glaubensfragen auslöst, 14 October 2026.
  • Stephan Köthe, AfD Esslingen: Statements on the sculpture and selection procedure, June and October 2026.
  • Artis Umbrae: DE LUPO DOMITO — a photographic interpretation of the legend of the Wolf of Gubbio.
Scroll to Top